In summer 2006, after a long period of hard discussions, Germany adopted the most comprehensive reform of its constitution since1949. According to theories on federalism, which build on the idea of rational traps, this reform should not have taken place. Any reform of the constitution, which would aim at separating interwoven responsibilities of the federal government and the Länder and at establishing more competition (decoupling), was predicted to fail. Analysts working from a variety of theoretical perspectives have produced convincing arguments which mainly point to the "stickiness" of institutions. Moreover, political actors occupy decision-making positions just for brief periods of time (Pierson 2000: 481) and, if they act as office-seekers, may care more about reelection and power positions but not about effective institutions. These arguments prompt the question: how is the German reform then to be explained? Contrary to most theoretical approaches, empirical findings verify that constitutional reforms happen more often than it is expected. By applying several theories to the puzzle of the reform of German federalism, my contribution tries to find out why the impossible has taken place. The paper stresses ideas like the window of opportunity, contextual factors and the importance of crises. It also discusses how these notions can be adapted to dominating theories which offer a more precise analytical framework.
목차
Abstract 1 Problems of German Federalism Before 2006 2 The impact of federal institutions on reform capacitiy 3 The Failure of the Reform in 2004 4 The Constitutional Reform of 2006 5 How to explain the failure of the constitutional reform in 2004 and its success in 2006? 5.1 Historical institutionalism 5.2 Veto-players 6 Conclusion References
저자
Sabine Kropp [ Professor, Heinrich-Heine-Universität Düsseldorf ]
한독사회과학회 [Koreanisch-Deutsche Gesellschaft Fuer Sozialwissenschaften]
설립연도
1990
분야
사회과학>사회과학일반
소개
독일 또는 독일어권 국가에서 사회과학분야를 전공한 학자들이 독일을 중심으로하여 유럽지역을 한국과 비교연구하기 위한 전문 학술단체임. 한국과 독일학자간에 사회과학분야에서의 공동연구를 심화하고, 이를 기반으로 하여 양국간의 학술교류및 각종 정보를 상호교환하기 위한 모임으로 설립 됨.
간행물
간행물명
한독사회과학논총 [Zeitschrift der Koreanisch-Deutschen Gesellschaft für Sozialwissenschaften]