한국의 시민종교 담론에 대한 비판적 고찰: 현대 한국 사회 분열을 중심으로
A Critical Examination of the Discourse on Civil Religion in Korea: Social Division in Contemporary Korean Society
The winter of 2024?2025 brought South Korean society to what many described as the brink of ‘civil war’. After the declaration of martial law on December 3, 2024, and the subsequent impeachment, people assembled in different squares within the same city, each group with its own rituals, songs, and sense of sacredness. The article views this division as at once a local instance of a worldwide crisis of democracy and a particular problem in South Korean society. Because of ‘compressed modernization’, South Korea is subject to the social malaise of ‘non-contemporaneity of the contemporaneous’, which is expressed in two ritual communities: the national ritual of the 1948 regime and the Minjung ritual associated with Gwangju in 1980 and June 1987. The article looks to the tradition of civil religion for guidance, but argues that this tradition can be applied to Korea only after the Korean discussion of civil religion has first undergone critical examination. By tracing the concept back through the writings of Rousseau, Durkheim, and Bellah, it finds two main characteristics: the discourse of civil religion arises when social divisions get out of hand, as a way of securing the basic civic creed that citizens of different sectarian communities must have in common; and it includes a transcendent reference point against which the state and those in power can be assessed. When these features are taken into account, both the common identification of civil religion with the Taegukgi rallies and the academic classification of competing ‘priestly’ and ‘prophetic’ forms of civil religion require critical revision. What separates civil religion from uncivil religion is not who controls the state but civility and tolerance toward other citizens; on this basis, the prophetic tradition is closer to the classical concern of civil religion. By way of conclusion, four proposals are suggested based on a single principle: that no fellow citizen should be excluded in the name of the sacred.
동북아시아문화학회 [The Association of North-east Asian Cultures]
설립연도
2000
분야
복합학>학제간연구
소개
동북아시아 문화의 다양성과 정체성을 연구 토론하고, 지역내 문화 교류의 다양한 모습을 연구하고 문화변동의 큰 틀을 집적함으로써 우리 민족 문화 및 상대 민족의 문화적 터전을 이해하여 문화공동체적 특성을 계발하고 상호 관련성의 강화를 유도하는 학술활동을 통해 동북아시아의 문화발전에 이바지함.