어촌 공간재생을 위한 마스터플랜 수립 가이드라인 개선 연구 - 전문가 인식과 마스터플랜 실증 사례를 중심으로 -
A Study on Improving Guidelines for Establishing Master Plans for Fishing Village Spatial Regeneration - Focusing on Expert Perceptions and Master Plan Case Studies -
This study diagnoses the implementation status of spatial environment master plans under Korea's Fishery New Deal 300 project and derives directions for guideline improvement. An Importance-Performance Analysis (IPA) was conducted with 36 planning professionals across 18 sub-items, and a guideline compliance evaluation was applied to three completed master plan reports. Overall mean importance (3.860) exceeded mean performance (3.357), indicating a persistent gap between professional expectations and field implementation. IPA results placed six items in Quadrant I (maintain), including spatial scope, coastal ecological landscape, and priority project selection; four items in Quadrant II (concentrate), including purpose/role, spatial management strategies, phased implementation, and budget securing; seven items in Quadrant III (low priority); and unit project derivation alone in Quadrant IV (reduce effort). Cross-analysis with report compliance evaluations identified three patterns: perception-reality alignment in execution-related items, quality-expectation gaps in purpose description and spatial management, and perceptual distortion in unit project derivation. Based on these findings, the study recommends mandatory standardization of budget and implementation planning formats, qualitative upgrading of purpose and management strategy guidelines, and procedural rebalancing from project listing toward execution capacity.
목차
Abstract 1. 서론 1.1 연구의 배경 및 목적 1.2 연구의 범위와 방법 2. 관련 연구 동향 3. 결과 및 고찰 3.1 공간환경 마스터플랜 IPA 평가결과 3.2 공간환경 마스터플랜 보고서 평가 4. 요약 및 결론 참고문헌