This study reviews theoretical comparisons regarding reentry issues of incarcerated people in order to promote a better understanding of individuals’ criminal desistance. There are three major competing criminal desistance theories, and they include the subjective (identity) theory explaining an individual’s subjective processes, structural (social bonds) theory focusing on structural conditions, and integrative (subjective-social model) theory describing personal commitment and motivation combined with structural resources. First, identity defined as a sense of self is directly linked to one’s motivation and behavioral guidelines. Thus, identity theory assumes that intentional changes in one’s sense of self are necessary for criminal desistance. The theory posits that only justice-involved individuals who intentionally transform their identities can attempt to utilize structural support to help them pursue change. Second, the structural theory on social bonds provides an appropriate theoretical foundation on how social bonds, such as employment, affect criminal desistance through a series of exogenous circumstances called turning points. Employment is an important example of a social bond for justice-involved individuals since it provides structure to one’s life. Third, the integrative model assumes that personal characteristics may interact within social contexts, in that an individual has to identify, select, and act within the structure they live in, through their cognitive transformation. This article also briefly discusses two major methodological challenges deriving from the utilization of the theory.
목차
ABSTRACT INTRODUCTION THEORIES OF CRIMINAL DESISTANCE: SUBJECTIVE VS. STRUCTURAL VS. INTEGRATIVE? Subjective Theory on Desistance: Identity Theory Structural Theory on Desistance: Theory of Social Bonds Integrative Theory on Desistance: Subjective-Social Model Synthesis of Theoretical Frameworks MAJOR METHODOLOGICAL CHALLENGES RELATED TO THE USE OF CRIMINAL DESISTANCE THEORY Conceptual Definition: What is Desistance? Source of Data and Measurement CONCLUSION REFERENCES
한국융합인문학회 [Korean Association of Converging Humanities]
설립연도
2013
분야
인문학>기타인문학
소개
본 학회는 인간의 삶의 질 향상과 관련된 제사항을 연구하고, 그에 관한 프로그램과 정책을 개발하는 것을 목적으로 하며, 또한 이를 통해 한국사회의 인본주의 진흥에 기여하는 것을 목적으로 합니다. 본 학회는 이러한 목적 달성을 위하여 학제간 연구와 융복합 연구를 지향하고 수행합니다.