근저당권의 소멸이 피담보채무부존재확인의 소에 미치는 효력에 관한 검토 - 대법원 2013. 08. 23. 선고 2012다17585 판결 중심으로 -
Examination about the effect which disappearance of a flexible mortgage exerts on the lawsuit of a check of the absence of a debt
It is a tendency of a judicial precedent that the collateralizing debt existing material check lawsuit and the erasion lawsuit of the Kun registration of settlement of mortgage are interpreted as the independent claim which may have influence mutually and does not have influence between claims. There is necessity which must solve the problem whether it must be consistent on a code of legal procedure, and must reflect the relation on a substantive law after all, and I think that I will solve such a problem through this incident judicial precedent. If registration of settlement of mortgage is erased, a debt to be collateralized will be opposed to holding of the Supreme Court that it is not an object of the check lawsuit by the past legal relation. It is judged that the lawsuit of checking the debt about the upper flexible mortgage to be collateralized not existing by the premise that the fact that the secured claim of the flexible mortgage was repaid to the judicial precedent of this incident was accepted, and, as for the flexible mortgage, it already disappeared was related with your father of the past legal relation. the obligation to the superior root mortgage in the case of the creditor keeping documents, such as a bill at debt, as usual from the time of a setup, or asserting this to be collateralized cannot be said to be the past legal relation. If the present judicial precedent which can be interpreted as the profits of the collateralizing debt existing reconfirmation being accepted in such a case, and the tendency of a theory are followed even if it calls it the past legal relation, this incident Supreme Court judicial precedent must have change which slips out of a judicial precedent conventionally.
목차
Ⅰ. 서론 Ⅱ. 피담보채무 부존재 확인의 소와 근저당권설정등기의 말소의 소 관계 Ⅲ. 과거의 법률관계에 대한 확인의 소의 허용여부 Ⅳ. 결론 참고문헌 Abstract
키워드
근저당권부종성채무부존재확인의 소송소송의 이익확인소송의 이익Flexible mortgageappendant nature of a lawsuitDebt absence check lawsuitProfits of a lawsuitProfits of a check lawsuit
동국대학교 비교법문화연구원 [The Institute of Comparative Law and Legal Culture]
설립연도
2000
분야
사회과학>법학
소개
본 연구소에서는 세계 각국의 새로운 법률제도를 그때그때 입수하여 이를 소개하고 한국 실정에 접목가능성을 연구·분석한다. 아울러 본 연구소는 국내의 각종 학술단체, 연구소, 연구기관과의 교류를 증진함은 물론 외국대학의 연구소와 공동연구를 통해 외국의 법문화와 학풍을 소개함으로써 대외적인 학풍선양에도 기여하게 함을 목적으로 한다.