Earticle

초록

영어

This thesis introduces the trends of korean courts' ruling on damages in medical malpractice cases for past 10 years. First of all, Korean courts' ruling have had a tendency to pay only non-economic damages for not taking the informed consent. If a doctor cannot get the informed consent from a patient, he compensate only non-economic damages for the infringement of self-determination rights of patient. It's enough for the plaintiff to prove the infringement of self-determination rights, if the plaintiff just want to get non-economic damages. The Korean Supreme court have ruled that if plaintiffs want to get economic damages for the infringement of self-determination rights or informed consent, plaintiffs must prove that the infringement of self-determination rights is the proximate cause of the economic damages of patient. There is another tendency for the Korean Supreme court to limit the damages in medical malpractice cases on the ground of patient's diseases' dangerousness or patient's idiosyncrasy. In the past courts often limit the damages only to 70~80% of total damages, but now a days courts mostly limit the damages to 20~30%. This thesis also introduce the Korean courts' trends about Valuing damages in personal injury actions awarded for gratuitously rendered nursing and medical care.

목차

IV. 책임제한 관련 판례의 동향
  1. 과실상계
  2. 피해자의 소인에 따른 책임제한
 V. 민법 제765조에 의한 배상액 경감
 VI. 치료비 및 병실료
  1. 기왕증에 대한 치료비
 VII. 신생아의 경우 개호가 필요한 시기(始期)
  1. 의료사고 발생일로부터 개호비를 인정한 사례
  2. 만 5세 이후부터(만 5세가 될 때까지는 개호비 제외)
  3. 만 3세 이후부터 - 비교적 짧은 기간의 개호를 인정할 경우에
  4. 만 4세 이후
  5. 변론종결일 이후
  6. 청구취지 감축을 통하여 원고가 구하는 바에 따라
  7. 만 5세까지는 0.5인만 인정한 사례
  8. 분석
 참고문헌
 ABSTRACT

키워드

손해배상 범위 설명의무 위자료 기회상실 조언설명 지도설명 자기결정권 위자료 산정 기준 책임제한 과실상계 치료비 병실료 개호비 Informed consnet Pain and suffering Loss of chance Family Damage Limitation of damage Cmparative damage Selbstbestimmungsrecht Diagnoseaufklärung Erlaufsaufklärung

저자

• 박영호 [ Young ho Park | 대구고등법원 판사 ]

참고문헌

발행기관

간행물