의료사고피해구제법안상 무과실책임주의 도입 문제
An Inducement problem on the principle liability without fault in a legislative bill of injury and relief in a medical accident
In the situation of bringing out of social problem about the medical accident and medical dispute, from 1988 the enactment activity for a legislative bill on conciliation of dispute has promoted, a legislative bill on prevention and relief of medical accident was again proposed in December, 2005. This bill has been faced rough going in review process of National Assembly. Because the purpose of this legislative bill is the conciliation of interest of between medical service consumer and medical service supplier, an item of issues of law is no-fault compensation scheme. However, as no-fault compensation scheme runs counter to the principle liability with fault in our civil law, as expected, whether the inducement is valid or, if induced, the problem is not must be totally reviewed. First of all, the general of principle liability without fault and especially the medical system in foreign countries are reviewed, by reviewing an issue and the pros and cons of the inducement of no-fault compensation scheme, this article draws the conclusion. After all, considering that the necessity adapting Gefahrdungschftung in medical accident as much as other industrial fields exists, the many provisions of the principle liability without fault exists in civil law and special law of our law system, and no-fault compensation scheme let legislative purpose be, to what extent, achieved by conciliating patient and doctor, the inducement of principle liability without fault in medical field is reasonable in the aspect of politic and legal system.
목차
Ⅰ. 서론 Ⅱ. 의료사고피해구제법 제정 작업 추진 경과 1. 우리나라의 의료분쟁 발생 현황 2. 의료사고피해구제법 제정경과 및 주요 쟁점 사항 Ⅲ. 무과실책임주의 및 우리 법제상 채택 조항 1. 무과실책임주의의 의의 2. 무과실책임의 근거 3. 외국의 무과실책임주의 입법례 4. 무과실책임주의의 기능 및 한계 5. 우리 법제상 무과실책임주의의 채택 Ⅳ. 의료사고피해구제법안상 무과실책임주의 도입 문제 1. 의료영역에서의 피해자구제 방식 2. 외국 의료제도에서의 입법례 3. 우리나라 의료법제에서의 도입여부에 관한 견해 Ⅴ. 종합 및 결론 참고문헌 ABSTRACT
키워드
medical accidentmedical disputea legislative bill on conciliation of disputea legislative bill on prevention and relief of medical accidentno-fault compensation schemeprinciple liability with faultprinciple liability without fault
대한의료법학회는 “법학계, 법조계, 의료계가 공동하여 의료법학의 학제적 연구와 판례 평석 등을 통하여 전문분야에 있어서의 법률문화 향상에 기여함을 그 목적”으로 하여 1994년 2월에 태동한 이후 1999년 4월 24일에 공식 출범한 이래 2006년 3월 30일 법무부 산하의 사단법인으로 등록된 세계적 수준의 순수 학술단체이다.